
https://www.artribune.com/attualita/2025/09/degrado-centri-storici-italia/
by Angelo Argento (*)
June, 2025
Cover Image: Piazza del Cinquecento, Roma_Copyright Artribune
Italy
The recent episode in Naples, with the attack on MP Borrelli live, is not an isolated event. It is the image of an Italy that is retreating, where legality dissolves and security remains only rhetoric. It is no longer a circumscribed phenomenon. From Venice to Florence, from Rome to Naples, the historic centres suffocate under the weight of illegality and abuse. The word “security”, deprived of its most authentic root – legality – is reduced to slogans. The numbers of the degradation of historic centres in Italy.
The numbers of the degradation of historic centres in Italy
In 2023, Florence was the third Italian province for reported crimes (6,060 per 100,000 inhabitants), preceded by Milan (7,116) and Rome (6,074). Naples and Venice are not far away. It is precisely in the places celebrated as universal symbols of beauty that petty crime is concentrated: thefts, muggings, pickpockets. Nationally, thefts fell by 14.4% between 2018 and 2023, but in tourist areas, pickpocketing remains stable (1% of the population), as do muggings (0.7%). 1.3% of citizens say they have suffered aggression or threats. Numbers that describe an insecure daily life, despite the fact that the national averages tell of an improvement.

Image: Rome, crowds of tourists in front of the Fountain of Trevi_Copyright Artribune
Tourism without community in the cities of Italy
To make the situation worse, overtourism. Venice, now reduced to less than 50,000 residents compared to 175,000 in the 1970s, hosts up to 85,000 visitors daily. 30% of the historic apartments have been converted into tourist rentals. The neighbourhoods are emptied of authentic life, they become fertile ground for marginalisation and widespread illegality.
From the museum to the open-air sewer
For years we have sold Italy as an open-air museum. But the step from the museum to the open-air sewer is getting shorter and shorter. The squares are invaded by dirt and criminal gangs, residents abandon, the state retreats. The rhetoric of “enhancement” clashes with the reality of a heritage that dies suffocated by the absence of rules.
The real emergency: legality
It is not a question of “decorum” but of collective dignity. The priority cannot be aesthetic: it is the restoration of legality as the foundation of security. Without legality there is no security. And without security there is no future for our historic centres, nor for Italy itself.
(*) Angelo Argento
Lawyer before the Supreme Court and before the Higher Courts. Professor of Cultural Heritage Legislation at the Brera National Academy of Fine Arts. President of Cultura Italiae, an association recognised as a UNESCO NGO.



