Current Affairs » Editorials and Opinions

by Mino Reganato

8 June 2026

Cover image: Visualisation of focus themes against a Florence backdrop – Credit: Quality Travel

 

The growth in arrivals recorded by official data reflects not only a real increase in demand but also the emergence of a hospitality market that has hitherto been partially invisible. Italian tourism is entering a new phase, one that is more complex than it appears at first glance. On the one hand, the figures show a country that remains highly attractive, capable of capturing international demand and drawing visitors to cities of art, seaside resorts, inland areas, villages, experiential destinations and lesser-known regions. On the other hand, however, there are figures that must be interpreted with great caution, because hidden within that apparent growth lies a phenomenon destined to profoundly affect our understanding of the market: the disclosure of unregistered non-hotel accommodation, driven by the introduction of the CIN, the National Identification Code.

This is not a marginal issue and does not concern only industry insiders; rather, it affects the credibility of tourism statistics and the ability of local authorities to manage a phenomenon that for years has grown faster than the regulations. For too long, part of the accommodation supply, particularly linked to short-term rentals and holiday lets, has existed in a grey area, visible on platforms but often invisible to public monitoring systems; now that grey area is becoming a map, a number, a code, a responsibility.

According to data released by the Ministry of the Interior via the Alloggiati Web platform, tourist arrivals in Italy rose from 173 million to over 185 million in 2025, representing a 7.1% increase. The most significant figure concerns the differing trends across sectors: arrivals at hotels rose from 101.6 million to 104.6 million, an increase of around 3%, whilst those at non-hotel accommodation grew from 71.4 million to 80.6 million, an increase of 13%.  At first glance, this would seem to signal robust and steady growth in demand, but in tourism, the surface figures are often the least interesting part of the story. Federalberghi has in fact highlighted a crucial point: part of that surge is not necessarily attributable to new tourists arriving in Italy, but to the emergence of accommodation that was not previously recorded. The association spoke of the need to interpret the data ‘ceteris paribus’, that is, by adjusting for the CIN effect, noting that over 600,000 accommodation units have been registered in the Ministry of Tourism’s database, of which, until last year, little or nothing was known. This is the crux of the matter, as we are not merely facing growth in tourism but an increase in the statistical visibility of tourism. It is a huge difference because if an apartment was already hosting guests but was not properly included in the official figures, its inclusion in the system today does not automatically generate new demand: it generates new measurement; in practice, it is like switching on the light in a room that already existed, where we have not built new square metres but have finally seen those that were in the dark.

The National Database of Accommodation Facilities (BDSR) and properties available for short-term or tourist rentals was created precisely for this purpose: to map the supply on a national scale, coordinate information between the State, Regions and local authorities, in order to combat irregular forms of accommodation and make every accommodation unit identifiable through the National Identification Code. The Ministry of Tourism specifies that the BDSR collects information such as the type of accommodation, location, capacity, the operator and the identification code; furthermore, the CIN must be displayed outside the premises and included in every advertisement published. This is where the issue becomes a matter of tourism policy rather than a mere bureaucratic formality, as the CIN is not simply a number to be hung on a door or included in an online advertisement, but a genuine milestone in the system’s development, where we finally know the details of who is providing accommodation, where it is provided, what the capacity is, what the requirements are, and within which administrative area.

However, we must avoid an ideological interpretation, because non-hotel accommodation is not the enemy of the hotel sector; such a stance would be short-sighted and out of step with market realities, as B&Bs, holiday homes, short-term rentals, farm stays, historic residences, professionally managed apartments and hybrid forms of hospitality meet a real demand that differs from that of traditional hotels. The contemporary tourist seeks features such as freedom, space, cuisine, privacy, family stays, more homely experiences and flexible stays; and in many areas, particularly in villages and inland regions, the non-hotel sector has even made it possible to create accommodation capacity where hotels no longer existed or were no longer economically viable. The problem, therefore, is not non-hotel accommodation but unregulated accommodation, with a substantial difference between those who operate in compliance with obligations, safety standards, tax regulations and commercial transparency, and those who instead exploit the fluidity of the digital world to evade the minimum requirements of hospitality.

Federalberghi had already highlighted, in institutional forums, the critical issues linked to the expansion of short-term rentals that had taken place for years under inadequate regulations and weak controls, posing risks to consumer safety; the same statement emphasised that the aim is not to create barriers between hotels and new forms of accommodation, but between those who respect the rules and those who ignore them. The tourism market does not need sectoral wars but symmetrical rules, effective controls and reliable data. Hotels have always had to comply with a complex system of requirements, such as fire safety, health and hygiene requirements, employment contracts, taxation, authorisations and so on. If another entity sells accommodation, collects payments, uses global platforms and participates in the tourism market, it cannot be treated as a purely domestic activity when, in reality, it operates as a hospitality business or micro-enterprise.

From this perspective, the CIN introduces a simple principle whereby those providing accommodation must be identifiable; this does not mean criminalising small-scale owners, nor unnecessarily burdening those who rent out properties correctly, but rather highlighting an essential element whereby hospitality cannot be invisible or managed improperly.

In this context, the way we interpret the statistics must also change, as year-on-year comparisons are likely to be skewed by the gradual disclosure of undeclared income. Whereas previously a significant proportion of accommodation was not recorded and is now included in the databases, the figures are rising partly because the scope of the data is expanding; this is certainly a positive development but must be explained, otherwise there is a risk of misleading the public with data that is not entirely accurate. In 2025, according to figures released by ISTAT, there is a divergence between arrivals and overnight stays: arrivals are down by 0.9%, whilst overnight stays are up by 2.3% compared to 2024. In the same press release, ISTAT reports a more marked increase in non-hotel overnight stays in the fourth quarter of 2025 compared to hotels, and this confirms that the market cannot be assessed using a single indicator for one simple reason: arrivals indicate how many people enter the system, overnight stays indicate how many nights they stay, turnover indicates how much economic value is generated, whilst profitability indicates how much of that value remains with the business and the local area.

Italian tourism, on the other hand, is all too often content with the most convenient figure: ‘arrivals have increased’, but an arrival does not pay salaries unless it generates profit margins, nor does it support investment unless it produces adequate revenue. A country can have more arrivals and less value, and this is often attributable to destinations that fill up but do not necessarily prosper. The rise of non-hotel accommodation therefore necessitates a qualitative leap in governance, where local authorities, in particular, cannot simply sit back and let the phenomenon unfold. The BDSR, among other things, also provides a ‘dashboard’ for local authorities featuring geolocation functions, an interactive map, the display of properties without a CIN, reports of missing properties, properties with unverified CINs, and a register of inspections. This means that local authorities finally have an operational tool to understand the actual distribution of accommodation, neighbourhood by neighbourhood, street by street, destination by destination. However, a tool alone cannot produce adequate governance; expertise and the ability to interpret the data and cross-reference it with other sources are required. Otherwise, the risk is having a modern database within administrations that continue to operate according to outdated logic.

Furthermore, this is not just an Italian issue: the European Union has introduced Regulation 2024/1028 to make the short-term rental market more transparent, establishing common rules on the collection and sharing of data between hosts, online platforms and public authorities. From 20 May 2026, the new European rules will apply and will provide, amongst other things, for verifiable registration numbers, checks on platforms and the periodic transmission of data on stays and nights booked. This development also demonstrates that we are not dealing with a mere national regulatory whim but with a genuine structural transformation of the European hospitality market. Platforms have created an immense, flexible and distributed offering, often useful to tourists and profitable for owners, but they have also produced side effects due to a lack of transparency and difficulties in fiscal and administrative control.

For hotels, this phase represents a challenge but also an opportunity where the the emergence of the informal sector reduces, at least in part, the competitive imbalance, and those who have always operated in the open cannot but view positively the inclusion within the regulatory framework of those selling accommodation, even if it would be a mistake to think that the CIN alone is enough to automatically restore competitiveness to the hotel sector, as hotels must continue to focus on quality and improve their relationship with the local area. For the regulated non-hotel sector, however, the CIN can become a form of legitimisation whereby those operating correctly distinguish themselves from illegal operators, and, in an increasingly crowded market, transparency becomes a reputational factor with a strong impact on tourists.

The real emergency, therefore, is not the existence of non-hotel accommodation but the fact that it has been allowed to grow for too long without a clear understanding and without a serious assessment of the impacts it was producing. It is certainly true that the CIN will not solve all the problems on its own and will not automatically stop illegal operations, but it represents an important starting point with a hoped-for return to the principle that those operating in tourism must be visible, identifiable and accountable. And perhaps, in a country that all too often thrives on tourism slogans, this is already a small revolution – not because it adds a code, but above all because it removes an excuse.