VENICE

by SERGIO PASCOLO

Published on 9 January 2026

Cover image and images in the text taken from Venezia, strana città (Venice, a strange city) – © Fabrizio Olivetti

‘Venice, the only refuge in our times of freedom, justice, peace, the only refuge of the good […] a city rich in gold but richer in renown, powerful in strength but more so in virtue, founded on solid marble but on even more solid foundations of firm and immovable civil harmony.’

This is how Francesco Petrarca described Venice in his “Letter to Pietro da Bologna” on 4 June 1364, collected in Epistole, Seniles. It should be noted that in our day, freedom, justice and peace in the world are under constant attack. We watch with dismay and helplessness as serious violations of universal human rights and international law occur, as the arbitrariness of force re-emerges, as pain is trivialised, as indifference prevails in the face of aggression and oppression affecting peoples and individuals. Western democracies, flattened by increasingly cynical standardisation, remain silent or look away. The result is the erosion of the values on which they themselves are founded, fuelled by the systematic manipulation of information and a profound hypocrisy that separates words from actions: peace is invoked while wars are financed, rights are proclaimed while they are trampled upon.

In this alarming international scenario, worrying about the future of Venice might seem secondary and marginal. Yet its history suggests exactly the opposite. The name by which the Venetians referred to their government, Serenissima Repubblica (Most Serene Republic), which spoke of peace and stability as distinctive features of the city, emphasised how balanced its political structure was.

In the upcoming election campaign for the new mayor and city government, there is a significant convergence of ideas in the coalition formed to offer an alternative to the current administration. Repopulation, residential policies, combating overtourism, overcoming the monoculture of tourism and rebuilding a diversified economic fabric, ecological mobility, protection of the environment and in particular of the lagoon: shared themes that outline a common trajectory. A vision reinforced by a call for unity and participation, with an appeal for the contribution of all those who care about the future of the city. An appeal to which I enthusiastically subscribe, joining the many passionate interventions that have recently appeared in this column and in the local press. In this spirit, I offer some reflections and ideas.

In the upcoming election campaign for the new mayor and city government, there is a significant convergence of ideas within the coalition formed to offer an alternative to the current administration. Repopulation, residential policies, combating overtourism, overcoming the monoculture of tourism and rebuilding a diversified economic fabric, ecological mobility, environmental protection and, in particular, protection of the lagoon: shared themes that outline a common trajectory. This vision is reinforced by a call for unity and participation, with an appeal for contributions from all those who care about the future of the city. An appeal to which I enthusiastically subscribe, joining the many passionate interventions that have recently appeared in this column and in the local press. In this spirit, I offer some reflections and ideas.

We live in a time when, in an international and national geopolitical context that sees the resurgence of hegemony and authoritarianism, the reversal of reality has become systematic practice. We are witnessing the reversal of the meaning of words, the public display of lies, the replacement of truth with so-called “alternative facts”. These manipulation techniques are accompanied by the propagandistic use of social and environmental issues, both in misleading and invasive advertising and in certain government narratives. For some time now, even in Venice, concepts such as sustainability, repopulation and attention to residence have been evoked by those who, in fact, have taken decisions that go in the opposite direction, in open contrast to the common good and driven by particular economic interests.

David Harvey predicted this: “The shameless commodification and commercialisation of everything is one of the hallmarks of our time.”

The case of Milan, often cited as a model, is a clear demonstration of this. As essayist and publisher Andrea Colamedici recently observed, “sustainability has been devoured by property speculation and the very distortion of the concept of progress which, when imbued with greed, transforms cities into quarries for the extraction of rents, making them simply unliveable for many”.

With this eloquent warning in mind, it becomes impossible not to ask: what does Venice want to be and, above all, what does it want to become? Is it possible that, based on its extraordinary diversity, it is the “courage to remain a city” that will shape its future prospects? It can be, provided that it is not considered merely a slogan, but is rooted in the soul of the city and its intrinsic values such as proximity, moderation, limits, harmony and, above all, the balance between human endeavour and nature, all of which are inalienable ingredients of its special nature.

The courage to remain a city is that of the citizens who resist, of the young people who want to stay or return after their studies, of the associations and committees that work tirelessly and deserve real political representation. But it is also the rejection of standardisation which, as Antonio Papisca, founder of the Human Rights Centre at the University of Padua, writes in his commentary on Article 27 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, “means the destruction of identity, the impoverishment of cultural heritage and an obstacle to cultural and artistic creativity.”

Rejection of standardisation is the same universal message we have seen in the unheard cry of young people against climate change, and more recently in the streets around the world against the genocide in Gaza.

In Venice, on 3 October 2025, we witnessed a demonstration that was huge in relation to the population and had a powerful symbolic value: the two marches, from the city on water and the city on dry land, met and joined together in a single large march on the Ponte della Libertà, a single cause, a single human sentiment, widely shared by the younger generations, who are demanding justice, transparency and truth. This is not the “party of no”, but a proactive movement that calls for peace, solidarity and environmental sustainability. This sentiment could have a significant impact on this election campaign: it is to be hoped that the mayoral candidates will enable us to identify a figure and a government team capable of representing that common sentiment and interpreting it as shared identity issues for the future of the city, with a forward-looking and exciting vision, both for the island city that does not want to become a tourist resort and for the mainland city that does not want to remain a suburb.

Reality versus narrative

Of course, the election campaign will certainly have to respond to the immediate needs of citizens. But in order to respond to the common good and the future of the city, those timely and short-term responses will carry even more weight if they are part of a coherent overall plan.

In an era of distorted communication, in which public debate, both global and local, asserts everything and its opposite, and discourse is often manipulative, the real dividing line is between truth and falsehood, between ambiguity and sincerity.

The difference will be made by the ability to speak clearly: let’s do an exercise with some illustrative questions, which are not exhaustive but strategic.

Does it make sense to talk about repopulation while continuing to authorise new hotels and the conversion of homes into accommodation facilities? Or would it be more consistent to intervene with clear rules and fiscal instruments to encourage residence, curb speculation and make homes available for those who live in the city?

Does it make sense to talk about sustainability and at the same time plan new and devastating excavations of deep channels to bring large ships back to the Marittima? Or does sustainability mean complying with the decree that provides for the offshore port and excluding new excavations and large ships in the Lagoon?

Does it make sense to talk about repopulation and sustainability if the City Council, Port Authority and Airport pursue contradictory objectives? Would the return of large cruise ships to Marittima encourage repopulation and attract young people to live in Venice? Or would it be more useful for that purpose to regenerate Marittima as an inhabited port, serving work and residence, planting trees and decementifying? And if the airport were to expand and bring in even more tourists, would this not compromise the goal of repopulation and residentiality? Should it not rather focus on strengthening its role as a regional hub for international trade for a productive and innovative metropolitan city?

Does it make sense to call for participation while taking away powers and resources from the municipalities, which are the primary means of representing citizens? Or does true participation mean creating real spaces for discussion of transparent governance, involving citizens, especially young people, and making them protagonists of the city’s project and their own future?

For a transition from today’s overtourism to quantitatively and qualitatively sustainable tourism, wouldn’t a tool such as the “Tourism Reinvestment Fund” recently adopted in Barcelona, a visitor contribution organised with a global information campaign, be necessary? By financing social housing, accessible workplaces, schools and nurseries, sustainable mobility, supporting craftsmanship, local services and ethically oriented businesses, and offering concessions to students, young people, families with children and the elderly, would this not effectively promote the repopulation of the city?

These questions, together with many other more complex ones, could form the basis for a strategy to be developed together. It is a patient task, with no simplistic shortcuts.

 

An idea of a city and a perspective

As we said at the beginning, the need to repopulate the city seems to be a shared goal, and we know that it is a complex process that requires consistency, listening, participation, adequate legal and fiscal tools, and above all, the ability to coordinate various synergistic actions with leadership that is up to the challenge. To be convincing, this major project must be supported and promoted by combining the “courage to remain a city” with a broad moral and civic mission capable of igniting a positive and propulsive spirit in the hearts of the younger generations, the true protagonists and guardians of the city of the future, within the global complexity of our time.

At this point, Petrarch’s powerful portrait of Venice becomes relevant and a source of inspiration: let us imagine Venice as a city that promotes peace, justice and human rights, that rejects war and, alongside its newly renewed twinning with Odessa, proposes a twinning with Gaza and recognises the State of Palestine; a universal repository of beauty, which understands beauty as a driving force for the common good; a city in which every piece of architecture contributes to defining public space, a feminine city, historically at the forefront of women’s emancipation, which conveys resilience, delicacy and kindness; a city of knowledge, culture and the arts, a city of education and research, a city at the forefront of climate and environmental policies, urban regeneration and sustainable living; a beacon of dignity, participation and civil harmony.

Venice and its Lagoon, an inseparable and exemplary fusion of urbanity and nature, will have an important mission and role in the world and will repopulate itself for this reason.

From this perspective, the election campaign can be transformed into a movement capable of involving the younger generations, making them protagonists, and of engaging conscious citizens and that large section of the population who are disappointed and no longer vote. In this same perspective, planetary membership finds its meaning and can be successful: visitors, citizens of the world, become conscious allies, proud to support the cause of the rebirth and regeneration of a city that resists standardisation and proposes an urban and social model based on justice and sustainability.

Recent history shows that by opposing standardisation, cities can distinguish themselves and become protagonists of change: Barcelona and Madrid in Spain, Genoa in Italy, and New York in the United States are some examples that have demonstrated this recently. This is even more true today, considering that Europe is redrawing its map of power, recognising cities not only as recipients of funds, but also as decision-making partners in EU policies and key players on the global stage.

What must be opposed is the standardisation of all forms of authoritarianism, the standardisation of the “normality” of global cities, the commodification that is destroying the socio-economic fabric of cities, and heavy infrastructure projects that alter the delicate environmental and behavioural balances essential to this urban organism, which is unique and extraordinary for the values it embodies.

Small in physical size but with enormous symbolic power, Venice, by becoming a bastion of civil progress, can be a beacon capable of transmitting a powerful and universal message of humanity and a sustainable future to the world. An ideal place to live for many.